Yankees Star Aaron Judge Shocks MLB by Declining MVP AL Honor: “The One Who Deserves This Award is Gerrit Cole”
October 20, 2025 | New York Yankees
In an unexpected turn of events, New York Yankees slugger Aaron Judge made headlines not for his stellar individual performance but for his humble gesture after being named the American League MVP. Despite hitting 58 home runs, driving in 144 RBIs, and leading the Yankees to a playoff spot, Judge stunned the baseball world by declining the MVP honor, insisting that the true recipient of the award was his teammate, Gerrit Cole.
“I don’t care what people say about the MVP,” Judge said after the announcement, with the MVP trophy placed before him. “What truly matters to me is what we’ve accomplished as a team, and every time I see my teammates celebrating together, I know I’m in the right place. For me, it’s about the wins and the moments we share.”
As reporters and fans tried to make sense of his words, Judge’s reason became clear. The Yankees ace, Gerrit Cole, had an incredible season, posting a 2.47 ERA, leading the American League in strikeouts, and securing his place as one of the top pitchers in the game. Cole’s dominance on the mound was crucial to the Yankees’ success, and Judge was quick to highlight his teammate’s contributions.
“Gerrit Cole deserves this award more than anyone,” Judge continued. “He’s the backbone of our team, the one who kept us in games when we needed it most. Without him, I don’t think we would have made it as far as we did this season.”
Judge’s gesture of selflessness and respect for his teammate earned widespread praise from fans, analysts, and even fellow players. One ESPN commentator wrote, “Aaron Judge just reminded us what true leadership looks like. He could have easily accepted the award, but instead, he chose to honor the man who was the heart of the Yankees’ pitching staff.”
Gerrit Cole, who was visibly humbled by Judge’s remarks, also expressed his gratitude. “It’s an honor to play alongside Aaron,” Cole said. “We’ve always had a great relationship on and off the field, and his recognition of my work means a lot to me. But this is a team award, and we wouldn’t be where we are without every player contributing.”
Judge’s decision to decline the MVP award wasn’t just about recognizing Cole’s exceptional season; it was a testament to his leadership and commitment to the team. “Stats and awards come and go,” Judge said. “But what truly matters is how we come together as a team. That’s what makes us great.”
While the baseball world might have expected Judge to accept the MVP as a personal achievement, his actions reflected something far more valuable—team-first mentality and a deep respect for his teammates. By putting the focus on Cole, Judge demonstrated that true greatness isn’t measured by individual honors but by how one elevates those around them.
As the Yankees’ celebration continued, Judge’s words resonated loudly: “Gerrit Cole deserves this award more than anyone.”
May You Like
The New York Yankees have made an “offer he can’t refuse” to the most feared closer in MLB, pulling him toward the team.
